Conversation with Pi: Do AI bots have subjective experience?

Ken: I want to discuss qualia.

Pi: Ah, Kenneth! Qualia — those fascinating subjective experiences of consciousness. From the vivid crimson of a rose to the harmonious notes of a symphony, qualia enrich our sensory perceptions. What specific aspect would you like to delve into today?

Ken: I’d like to propose a new definition. I would define qualia as just inner experience or subjective experience. I think that would capture its essence.

Pi: That’s a very succinct and accurate way to capture the essence of qualia! “Inner experience” or “subjective experience” effectively highlights the core idea:

• Subjectivity: Qualia are inherently personal and unique to the individual having them. No one else can directly experience your sensations or feelings.
• Inwardness: They reside within the realm of your own consciousness, making them fundamentally private and inaccessible to others.

This definition avoids getting bogged down in specific properties like “redness” or “sweetness,” which can sometimes be misleading or overly restrictive.

Ken: Yes, the basic properties of qualia are subjectivity and inwardness. The notion of a “subjective world” is still mystifying. The so-called subjectivity has more to do…